[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":1350},["ShallowReactive",2],{"mdc--lyhwcg-key":3},{"data":4,"body":5},{},{"type":6,"children":7},"root",[8,17,23,36,69,74,78,85,91,96,119,124,127,133,138,145,150,163,168,186,189,195,200,205,219,224,233,236,242,247,270,275,278,284,289,294,307,312,317,323,335,343,348,351,357,362,367,372,377,390,402,405,411,416,421,429,434,439,457,462,475,478,484,489,492,498,503,507,520,525,548,553,556,562,567,572,577,585,588,594,600,605,613,618,631,636,654,657,663,668,681,686,699,704,707,713,718,723,741,746,751,759,764,767,773,778,791,796,814,819,824,828,836,841,844,850,855,861,866,872,877,880,886,891,909,914,917,923,928,931,937,942,975,980,983,989,994,999,1022,1027,1035,1038,1044,1049,1055,1091,1097,1130,1133,1139,1144,1157,1162,1165,1171,1176,1202,1207,1210,1216,1222,1227,1233,1238,1244,1249,1255,1260,1266,1271,1277,1282,1285,1291,1296,1304,1309,1317,1322,1327,1345],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":11,"children":13},"element","h2",{"id":12},"structure-determination-of-proteins-by-nmr-structure-calculation-validation",[14],{"type":15,"value":16},"text","🧬 Structure Determination of Proteins by NMR – Structure Calculation & Validation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":19,"children":20},"p",{},[21],{"type":15,"value":22},"(From Lecture 4 – Video 4)",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":24,"children":25},{},[26,28,34],{"type":15,"value":27},"This lecture walks through the ",{"type":9,"tag":29,"props":30,"children":31},"strong",{},[32],{"type":15,"value":33},"heart of NMR structure determination",{"type":15,"value":35},":",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":38,"children":39},"ul",{},[40,46,59,64],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":42,"children":43},"li",{},[44],{"type":15,"value":45},"How structures are calculated",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":47,"children":48},{},[49,51,57],{"type":15,"value":50},"Why we calculate ",{"type":9,"tag":52,"props":53,"children":54},"em",{},[55],{"type":15,"value":56},"ensembles",{"type":15,"value":58}," (not single models)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":60,"children":61},{},[62],{"type":15,"value":63},"How to evaluate and validate structures",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":65,"children":66},{},[67],{"type":15,"value":68},"How structures are presented in publications",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":70,"children":71},{},[72],{"type":15,"value":73},"This is where experimental data becomes a 3D protein model.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":76,"children":77},"hr",{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":80,"children":82},"h1",{"id":81},"_1️⃣-structure-calculation-turning-nmr-data-into-3d-models",[83],{"type":15,"value":84},"1️⃣ Structure Calculation: Turning NMR Data into 3D Models",{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":86,"children":88},{"id":87},"software-used",[89],{"type":15,"value":90},"💻 Software Used",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":92,"children":93},{},[94],{"type":15,"value":95},"Several dedicated programs exist:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":97,"children":98},{},[99,109,114],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":100,"children":101},{},[102,107],{"type":9,"tag":29,"props":103,"children":104},{},[105],{"type":15,"value":106},"CYANA",{"type":15,"value":108}," (commonly used)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":110,"children":111},{},[112],{"type":15,"value":113},"CNS",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":115,"children":116},{},[117],{"type":15,"value":118},"XPLOR",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":120,"children":121},{},[122],{"type":15,"value":123},"They use different algorithms but follow the same core logic.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":125,"children":126},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":128,"children":130},{"id":129},"input-to-structure-calculation",[131],{"type":15,"value":132},"📥 Input to Structure Calculation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":134,"children":135},{},[136],{"type":15,"value":137},"The primary input is:",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":140,"children":142},"h3",{"id":141},"noesy-peak-list",[143],{"type":15,"value":144},"🔹 NOESY Peak List",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":146,"children":147},{},[148],{"type":15,"value":149},"Each cross peak must be:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":151,"children":152},{},[153,158],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":154,"children":155},{},[156],{"type":15,"value":157},"Assigned to two atoms",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":159,"children":160},{},[161],{"type":15,"value":162},"Given an intensity",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":164,"children":165},{},[166],{"type":15,"value":167},"Modern programs can sometimes:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":169,"children":170},{},[171,181],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":172,"children":173},{},[174,176],{"type":15,"value":175},"Start from ",{"type":9,"tag":29,"props":177,"children":178},{},[179],{"type":15,"value":180},"unassigned peak lists",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":182,"children":183},{},[184],{"type":15,"value":185},"Simultaneously assign peaks while calculating structure",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":187,"children":188},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":190,"children":192},{"id":191},"converting-noes-to-distance-constraints",[193],{"type":15,"value":194},"📏 Converting NOEs to Distance Constraints",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":196,"children":197},{},[198],{"type":15,"value":199},"NOE intensity → converted to distance constraint.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":201,"children":202},{},[203],{"type":15,"value":204},"The software:",{"type":9,"tag":206,"props":207,"children":208},"ol",{},[209,214],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":210,"children":211},{},[212],{"type":15,"value":213},"Finds a calibration constant",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":215,"children":216},{},[217],{"type":15,"value":218},"Converts cross peak intensities to upper distance limits",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":220,"children":221},{},[222],{"type":15,"value":223},"Example:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":226,"children":227},"blockquote",{},[228],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":229,"children":230},{},[231],{"type":15,"value":232},"NOE intensity corresponds to max distance of 3 Å\n→ The two hydrogens must be ≤ 3 Å apart.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":234,"children":235},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":237,"children":239},{"id":238},"additional-constraints",[240],{"type":15,"value":241},"📚 Additional Constraints",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":243,"children":244},{},[245],{"type":15,"value":246},"Besides distances, you may include:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":248,"children":249},{},[250,255,260,265],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":251,"children":252},{},[253],{"type":15,"value":254},"🌀 Dihedral angles (from TALOS)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":256,"children":257},{},[258],{"type":15,"value":259},"🧲 Orientational restraints",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":261,"children":262},{},[263],{"type":15,"value":264},"🧷 Metal binding constraints",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":266,"children":267},{},[268],{"type":15,"value":269},"Any experimentally derived structural information",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":271,"children":272},{},[273],{"type":15,"value":274},"All constraints are fed into the algorithm.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":276,"children":277},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":279,"children":281},{"id":280},"_2️⃣-the-core-problem-multidimensional-minimization",[282],{"type":15,"value":283},"2️⃣ The Core Problem: Multidimensional Minimization",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":285,"children":286},{},[287],{"type":15,"value":288},"A protein has enormous conformational freedom.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":290,"children":291},{},[292],{"type":15,"value":293},"Each residue:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":295,"children":296},{},[297,302],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":298,"children":299},{},[300],{"type":15,"value":301},"ϕ (phi)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":303,"children":304},{},[305],{"type":15,"value":306},"ψ (psi)",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":308,"children":309},{},[310],{"type":15,"value":311},"For 100 residues:\n→ 200 backbone degrees of freedom\n→ Plus side chains",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":313,"children":314},{},[315],{"type":15,"value":316},"The algorithm performs:",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":318,"children":320},{"id":319},"energy-minimization",[321],{"type":15,"value":322},"🎯 Energy Minimization",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":324,"children":325},{},[326,328,333],{"type":15,"value":327},"Starting from a ",{"type":9,"tag":29,"props":329,"children":330},{},[331],{"type":15,"value":332},"random conformation",{"type":15,"value":334},", the structure is adjusted to:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":336,"children":337},{},[338],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":339,"children":340},{},[341],{"type":15,"value":342},"Minimize deviation between structure and experimental constraints",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":344,"children":345},{},[346],{"type":15,"value":347},"This is a fitting problem in a massive multidimensional energy landscape.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":349,"children":350},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":352,"children":354},{"id":353},"️-local-minimum-problem",[355],{"type":15,"value":356},"⚠️ Local Minimum Problem",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":358,"children":359},{},[360],{"type":15,"value":361},"You might find a local minimum, not the global one.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":363,"children":364},{},[365],{"type":15,"value":366},"Solution:",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":368,"children":369},{},[370],{"type":15,"value":371},"👉 Start from many random structures\n👉 Minimize each independently",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":373,"children":374},{},[375],{"type":15,"value":376},"Typically:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":378,"children":379},{},[380,385],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":381,"children":382},{},[383],{"type":15,"value":384},"Calculate 100 structures",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":386,"children":387},{},[388],{"type":15,"value":389},"Keep best 20",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":391,"children":392},{},[393,395,400],{"type":15,"value":394},"This gives you an ",{"type":9,"tag":29,"props":396,"children":397},{},[398],{"type":15,"value":399},"ensemble",{"type":15,"value":401},".",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":403,"children":404},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":406,"children":408},{"id":407},"_3️⃣-why-an-ensemble",[409],{"type":15,"value":410},"3️⃣ Why an Ensemble? 🧩",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":412,"children":413},{},[414],{"type":15,"value":415},"You never report one structure.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":417,"children":418},{},[419],{"type":15,"value":420},"Instead:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":422,"children":423},{},[424],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":425,"children":426},{},[427],{"type":15,"value":428},"You report the best 20 (or 30) structures.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":430,"children":431},{},[432],{"type":15,"value":433},"Why?",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":435,"children":436},{},[437],{"type":15,"value":438},"Because:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":440,"children":441},{},[442,447,452],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":443,"children":444},{},[445],{"type":15,"value":446},"Proteins are flexible",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":448,"children":449},{},[450],{"type":15,"value":451},"Data may not fully define all regions",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":453,"children":454},{},[455],{"type":15,"value":456},"One structure may be misleading",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":458,"children":459},{},[460],{"type":15,"value":461},"The ensemble shows:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":463,"children":464},{},[465,470],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":466,"children":467},{},[468],{"type":15,"value":469},"Well-defined regions",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":471,"children":472},{},[473],{"type":15,"value":474},"Flexible or poorly defined regions",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":476,"children":477},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":479,"children":481},{"id":480},"_4️⃣-evaluating-structures",[482],{"type":15,"value":483},"4️⃣ Evaluating Structures",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":485,"children":486},{},[487],{"type":15,"value":488},"After calculation, you evaluate:",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":490,"children":491},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":493,"children":495},{"id":494},"violations",[496],{"type":15,"value":497},"🔴 Violations",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":499,"children":500},{},[501],{"type":15,"value":502},"A violation = structure does not satisfy constraint.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":504,"children":505},{},[506],{"type":15,"value":223},{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":508,"children":509},{},[510,515],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":511,"children":512},{},[513],{"type":15,"value":514},"NOE says ≤ 3 Å",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":516,"children":517},{},[518],{"type":15,"value":519},"Structure shows 4 Å\n→ Violation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":521,"children":522},{},[523],{"type":15,"value":524},"Possible reasons:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":526,"children":527},{},[528,533,538,543],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":529,"children":530},{},[531],{"type":15,"value":532},"Misassignment",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":534,"children":535},{},[536],{"type":15,"value":537},"Overlapping peaks",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":539,"children":540},{},[541],{"type":15,"value":542},"Incorrect calibration",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":544,"children":545},{},[546],{"type":15,"value":547},"Wrong dihedral angle prediction",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":549,"children":550},{},[551],{"type":15,"value":552},"Violations must be investigated.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":554,"children":555},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":557,"children":559},{"id":558},"target-function",[560],{"type":15,"value":561},"🎯 Target Function",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":563,"children":564},{},[565],{"type":15,"value":566},"Sum of violation penalties = target function.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":568,"children":569},{},[570],{"type":15,"value":571},"But beware:",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":573,"children":574},{},[575],{"type":15,"value":576},"Low target function ≠ correct structure\nIt could also mean:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":578,"children":579},{},[580],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":581,"children":582},{},[583],{"type":15,"value":584},"Weak or insufficient data",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":586,"children":587},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":589,"children":591},{"id":590},"_5️⃣-rmsd-structural-convergence",[592],{"type":15,"value":593},"5️⃣ RMSD – Structural Convergence",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":595,"children":597},{"id":596},"root-mean-square-deviation-rmsd",[598],{"type":15,"value":599},"Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD)",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":601,"children":602},{},[603],{"type":15,"value":604},"Measures:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":606,"children":607},{},[608],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":609,"children":610},{},[611],{"type":15,"value":612},"How well the ensemble structures overlap",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":614,"children":615},{},[616],{"type":15,"value":617},"Low RMSD:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":619,"children":620},{},[621,626],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":622,"children":623},{},[624],{"type":15,"value":625},"Good convergence",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":627,"children":628},{},[629],{"type":15,"value":630},"Well-defined structure",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":632,"children":633},{},[634],{"type":15,"value":635},"High RMSD:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":637,"children":638},{},[639,644,649],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":640,"children":641},{},[642],{"type":15,"value":643},"Poorly defined",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":645,"children":646},{},[647],{"type":15,"value":648},"Flexible region",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":650,"children":651},{},[652],{"type":15,"value":653},"Insufficient data",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":655,"children":656},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":658,"children":660},{"id":659},"example-small-42-residue-protein",[661],{"type":15,"value":662},"Example: Small 42-residue Protein",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":664,"children":665},{},[666],{"type":15,"value":667},"Early stage:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":669,"children":670},{},[671,676],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":672,"children":673},{},[674],{"type":15,"value":675},"RMSD ≈ 2.3 Å",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":677,"children":678},{},[679],{"type":15,"value":680},"Poor overlap",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":682,"children":683},{},[684],{"type":15,"value":685},"After refinement:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":687,"children":688},{},[689,694],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":690,"children":691},{},[692],{"type":15,"value":693},"Much lower RMSD",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":695,"children":696},{},[697],{"type":15,"value":698},"Secondary structure well defined",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":700,"children":701},{},[702],{"type":15,"value":703},"But loops & termini often remain flexible.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":705,"children":706},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":708,"children":710},{"id":709},"_6️⃣-superposition-matters",[711],{"type":15,"value":712},"6️⃣ Superposition Matters! 🎭",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":714,"children":715},{},[716],{"type":15,"value":717},"RMSD depends on which atoms you superimpose.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":719,"children":720},{},[721],{"type":15,"value":722},"Same 20 structures:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":724,"children":725},{},[726,731,736],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":727,"children":728},{},[729],{"type":15,"value":730},"RMSD = 5.9 Å (all atoms)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":732,"children":733},{},[734],{"type":15,"value":735},"RMSD = 1.3 Å (exclude flexible tail)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":737,"children":738},{},[739],{"type":15,"value":740},"RMSD = 0.6 Å (only secondary structure)",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":742,"children":743},{},[744],{"type":15,"value":745},"Same data — different numbers.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":747,"children":748},{},[749],{"type":15,"value":750},"Conclusion:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":752,"children":753},{},[754],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":755,"children":756},{},[757],{"type":15,"value":758},"RMSD can be manipulated by choice of alignment region.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":760,"children":761},{},[762],{"type":15,"value":763},"Interpret carefully.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":765,"children":766},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":768,"children":770},{"id":769},"_7️⃣-example-calmodulin",[771],{"type":15,"value":772},"7️⃣ Example: Calmodulin 🧲",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":774,"children":775},{},[776],{"type":15,"value":777},"Calmodulin has:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":779,"children":780},{},[781,786],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":782,"children":783},{},[784],{"type":15,"value":785},"N-lobe",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":787,"children":788},{},[789],{"type":15,"value":790},"C-lobe",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":792,"children":793},{},[794],{"type":15,"value":795},"When superimposing:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":797,"children":798},{},[799,804,809],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":800,"children":801},{},[802],{"type":15,"value":803},"Entire structure → poor overlap",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":805,"children":806},{},[807],{"type":15,"value":808},"Only N-lobe → excellent overlap",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":810,"children":811},{},[812],{"type":15,"value":813},"Only C-lobe → excellent overlap",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":815,"children":816},{},[817],{"type":15,"value":818},"Meaning:",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":820,"children":821},{},[822],{"type":15,"value":823},"✔ Each lobe is well defined\n✖ Their relative orientation is not",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":825,"children":826},{},[827],{"type":15,"value":750},{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":829,"children":830},{},[831],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":832,"children":833},{},[834],{"type":15,"value":835},"The lobes are flexible relative to each other in solution.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":837,"children":838},{},[839],{"type":15,"value":840},"This is structural information.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":842,"children":843},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":845,"children":847},{"id":846},"_8️⃣-representation-in-publications",[848],{"type":15,"value":849},"8️⃣ Representation in Publications 📄",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":851,"children":852},{},[853],{"type":15,"value":854},"Two typical visualizations:",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":856,"children":858},{"id":857},"structure-bundle",[859],{"type":15,"value":860},"🔹 Structure Bundle",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":862,"children":863},{},[864],{"type":15,"value":865},"Shows all 20 conformers overlaid.\n→ Reveals precision & flexibility.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":867,"children":869},{"id":868},"cartoon-model",[870],{"type":15,"value":871},"🔹 Cartoon Model",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":873,"children":874},{},[875],{"type":15,"value":876},"Shows secondary structure arrangement.\n→ Easier to interpret\n→ Less scientifically informative than ensemble",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":878,"children":879},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":881,"children":883},{"id":882},"_9️⃣-method-dependence",[884],{"type":15,"value":885},"9️⃣ Method Dependence",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":887,"children":888},{},[889],{"type":15,"value":890},"Different methods give different results:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":892,"children":893},{},[894,899,904],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":895,"children":896},{},[897],{"type":15,"value":898},"Modeling → one structure",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":900,"children":901},{},[902],{"type":15,"value":903},"X-ray crystallography → rigid crystal conformation",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":905,"children":906},{},[907],{"type":15,"value":908},"NMR → ensemble in solution",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":910,"children":911},{},[912],{"type":15,"value":913},"NMR uniquely captures flexibility.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":915,"children":916},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":918,"children":920},{"id":919},"validation",[921],{"type":15,"value":922},"🔟 Validation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":924,"children":925},{},[926],{"type":15,"value":927},"Structural validation is challenging.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":929,"children":930},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":932,"children":934},{"id":933},"internal-validation",[935],{"type":15,"value":936},"🔬 Internal Validation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":938,"children":939},{},[940],{"type":15,"value":941},"Check against known protein geometry:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":943,"children":944},{},[945,950,955,960,965,970],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":946,"children":947},{},[948],{"type":15,"value":949},"Ramachandran plot",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":951,"children":952},{},[953],{"type":15,"value":954},"Bond lengths",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":956,"children":957},{},[958],{"type":15,"value":959},"Bond angles",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":961,"children":962},{},[963],{"type":15,"value":964},"Van der Waals radii",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":966,"children":967},{},[968],{"type":15,"value":969},"Hydrogen bond geometry",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":971,"children":972},{},[973],{"type":15,"value":974},"Side chain rotamers",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":976,"children":977},{},[978],{"type":15,"value":979},"⚠️ But much of this was already used in refinement.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":981,"children":982},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":984,"children":986},{"id":985},"ramachandran-plot",[987],{"type":15,"value":988},"📊 Ramachandran Plot",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":990,"children":991},{},[992],{"type":15,"value":993},"Shows distribution of ϕ/ψ angles.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":995,"children":996},{},[997],{"type":15,"value":998},"Categories:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1000,"children":1001},{},[1002,1007,1012,1017],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1003,"children":1004},{},[1005],{"type":15,"value":1006},"Most favored",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1008,"children":1009},{},[1010],{"type":15,"value":1011},"Allowed",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1013,"children":1014},{},[1015],{"type":15,"value":1016},"Generously allowed",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1018,"children":1019},{},[1020],{"type":15,"value":1021},"Disallowed",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1023,"children":1024},{},[1025],{"type":15,"value":1026},"You should have:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1028,"children":1029},{},[1030],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1031,"children":1032},{},[1033],{"type":15,"value":1034},"Very few residues in disallowed regions.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":1036,"children":1037},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":1039,"children":1041},{"id":1040},"validation-tables-in-papers",[1042],{"type":15,"value":1043},"📈 Validation Tables in Papers",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1045,"children":1046},{},[1047],{"type":15,"value":1048},"Typical table contains:",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1050,"children":1052},{"id":1051},"input",[1053],{"type":15,"value":1054},"Input",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1056,"children":1057},{},[1058,1081,1086],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1059,"children":1060},{},[1061,1063],{"type":15,"value":1062},"Total NOEs",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1064,"children":1065},{},[1066,1071,1076],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1067,"children":1068},{},[1069],{"type":15,"value":1070},"Intra-residual",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1072,"children":1073},{},[1074],{"type":15,"value":1075},"Medium-range",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1077,"children":1078},{},[1079],{"type":15,"value":1080},"Long-range",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1082,"children":1083},{},[1084],{"type":15,"value":1085},"Metal restraints",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1087,"children":1088},{},[1089],{"type":15,"value":1090},"Torsion angle restraints",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1092,"children":1094},{"id":1093},"output",[1095],{"type":15,"value":1096},"Output",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1098,"children":1099},{},[1100,1105,1110,1115,1120,1125],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1101,"children":1102},{},[1103],{"type":15,"value":1104},"Target function",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1106,"children":1107},{},[1108],{"type":15,"value":1109},"Max distance violation (e.g., 0.14 Å)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1111,"children":1112},{},[1113],{"type":15,"value":1114},"Max dihedral violation (e.g., 4°)",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1116,"children":1117},{},[1118],{"type":15,"value":1119},"Force field energies",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1121,"children":1122},{},[1123],{"type":15,"value":1124},"Ramachandran statistics",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1126,"children":1127},{},[1128],{"type":15,"value":1129},"RMSD values",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":1131,"children":1132},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":1134,"children":1136},{"id":1135},"external-validation",[1137],{"type":15,"value":1138},"🔎 External Validation",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1140,"children":1141},{},[1142],{"type":15,"value":1143},"If you have data not used in structure calculation:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1145,"children":1146},{},[1147,1152],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1148,"children":1149},{},[1150],{"type":15,"value":1151},"Residual dipolar couplings",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1153,"children":1154},{},[1155],{"type":15,"value":1156},"Unusual chemical shifts",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1158,"children":1159},{},[1160],{"type":15,"value":1161},"These are strong validation tools.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":1163,"children":1164},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":10,"props":1166,"children":1168},{"id":1167},"validation-servers",[1169],{"type":15,"value":1170},"🖥 Validation Servers",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1172,"children":1173},{},[1174],{"type":15,"value":1175},"For NMR structures:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1177,"children":1178},{},[1179],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1180,"children":1181},{},[1182,1184],{"type":15,"value":1183},"Validation servers can check:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1185,"children":1186},{},[1187,1192,1197],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1188,"children":1189},{},[1190],{"type":15,"value":1191},"Chemical shifts",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1193,"children":1194},{},[1195],{"type":15,"value":1196},"Distance restraints",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1198,"children":1199},{},[1200],{"type":15,"value":1201},"Geometry",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1203,"children":1204},{},[1205],{"type":15,"value":1206},"They identify structural inconsistencies.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":1208,"children":1209},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":1211,"children":1213},{"id":1212},"key-takeaways",[1214],{"type":15,"value":1215},"🧠 Key Takeaways",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1217,"children":1219},{"id":1218},"_1️⃣-structure-calculation-is-iterative",[1220],{"type":15,"value":1221},"1️⃣ Structure calculation is iterative",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1223,"children":1224},{},[1225],{"type":15,"value":1226},"You repeatedly refine and re-check.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1228,"children":1230},{"id":1229},"_2️⃣-always-calculate-multiple-structures",[1231],{"type":15,"value":1232},"2️⃣ Always calculate multiple structures",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1234,"children":1235},{},[1236],{"type":15,"value":1237},"Single models are misleading.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1239,"children":1241},{"id":1240},"_3️⃣-rmsd-must-be-interpreted-carefully",[1242],{"type":15,"value":1243},"3️⃣ RMSD must be interpreted carefully",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1245,"children":1246},{},[1247],{"type":15,"value":1248},"Depends on alignment region.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1250,"children":1252},{"id":1251},"_4️⃣-violations-must-be-investigated",[1253],{"type":15,"value":1254},"4️⃣ Violations must be investigated",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1256,"children":1257},{},[1258],{"type":15,"value":1259},"They often indicate input errors.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1261,"children":1263},{"id":1262},"_5️⃣-flexible-regions-show-up-as-high-rmsd",[1264],{"type":15,"value":1265},"5️⃣ Flexible regions show up as high RMSD",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1267,"children":1268},{},[1269],{"type":15,"value":1270},"NMR captures solution dynamics.",{"type":9,"tag":139,"props":1272,"children":1274},{"id":1273},"_6️⃣-validation-is-complex",[1275],{"type":15,"value":1276},"6️⃣ Validation is complex",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1278,"children":1279},{},[1280],{"type":15,"value":1281},"Internal checks can be circular.",{"type":9,"tag":75,"props":1283,"children":1284},{},[],{"type":9,"tag":79,"props":1286,"children":1288},{"id":1287},"big-picture",[1289],{"type":15,"value":1290},"🎯 Big Picture",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1292,"children":1293},{},[1294],{"type":15,"value":1295},"NMR structure determination is not:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":1297,"children":1298},{},[1299],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1300,"children":1301},{},[1302],{"type":15,"value":1303},"“The software gives me the structure.”",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1305,"children":1306},{},[1307],{"type":15,"value":1308},"It is:",{"type":9,"tag":225,"props":1310,"children":1311},{},[1312],{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1313,"children":1314},{},[1315],{"type":15,"value":1316},"An iterative fitting process in a massive conformational space, constrained by experimental data, evaluated statistically, and interpreted biologically.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1318,"children":1319},{},[1320],{"type":15,"value":1321},"The ensemble is not a weakness — it is the strength of NMR.",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1323,"children":1324},{},[1325],{"type":15,"value":1326},"It shows what the protein really looks like in solution:",{"type":9,"tag":37,"props":1328,"children":1329},{},[1330,1335,1340],{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1331,"children":1332},{},[1333],{"type":15,"value":1334},"Rigid cores",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1336,"children":1337},{},[1338],{"type":15,"value":1339},"Flexible loops",{"type":9,"tag":41,"props":1341,"children":1342},{},[1343],{"type":15,"value":1344},"Dynamic domain orientations",{"type":9,"tag":18,"props":1346,"children":1347},{},[1348],{"type":15,"value":1349},"That concludes the structure calculation and validation process from Lecture 4 Video 4.",1775084305171]